Jonathan Sutherland's forced fumble on an Indiana punt return early in the fourth quarter proved essential to Penn State's 33-28 win.
Penn State Men's Soccer dropped a cagey and physical non-conference match to James Madison on the road.
For the second consecutive match, Russ Rose's Nittany Lions beat the Scarlet Knights in straight sets. Penn State has now won eight in a row.
Penn State completed its second consecutive sweep and stayed perfect this season.
Toney finished the game with four sacks, including a crucial one on the Hoosiers' final drive of the game late in the fourth quarter.
The special teams unit didn't cost Penn State the game against Indiana, but it didn't look pretty.