Three goals from both Kristin O'Neill and Taylor Regan pushed the Nittany Lions to victory over the Hawks.
Ethan Long served as Penn State's hot hand with three goals and two assists, but his efforts weren't enough to lead the team to victory.
A valiant comeback attempt was not enough to extend the Nittany Lions' Cinderella run in the Big Ten Tournament.
Penn State softball (10-11) finished off its spring break travels with a double-header against Delaware Friday.
Penn State is encouraging students to postpone their return from spring break until Sunday, March 13.
"The Indy Fuel’s ownership and leaders want to apologize to Liam for the distress and upheaval this incident caused him, and we will continue to cheer for him as his career progresses," the team said in a statement.