The Nittany Lions earned 172.5 points through six sessions.
Aaron Brooks and Carter Starocci are the first Penn State wrestlers to secure four individual national titles.
In a cold and windy day at Beard Field, Penn State earned a convincing win over the Hoosiers.
The Nittany Lions committed four errors in the loss.
Kasak won seven straight consolation matches to take third place in the NCAA Championships.
Brooks is the fifth Nittany Lion to win the trophy.