PSU news by
Penn State's student blog

Topics

About

Big Ten Referees Respond to Blown Calls in Ohio State Game

I’m not usually one to blame the referees for the outcome of a game, or whine generally about poor officiating. Those voices tend to depend on perspective and rooting interest. A blown pass interference call, a crucial holding call that could’ve gone either way, or the whole litany of other judgement penalties Big Ten Refs consistently screw up usually balance out for a team over the course of the year.

However, when the officiating is so bad that a pool reporter is allowed to interview the crew chief (John O’Neill) and replay official (Tom Fiedler) after the game, you know something is fucked up.

“I’d love to come in here and tell you what I really think,” James Franklin said on the officiating after the game. “But that wouldn’t be appropriate.”

There are two penalties in particular from last night that resulted in Ohio State scores that were indisputably and objectively incorrect calls.

First was Christian Hackenberg’s admittedly poor pass that was “picked off” by Ohio State’s Vonn Bell. You can see the ball clearly hitting the ground — this is not in question. This play was reviewed and the call inexplicably stood. That gave the Buckeyes the ball in great field position at Penn State’s 39 yard-line, which resulted in an easy touchdown (only one of two Ohio State would score on the day).

To screw up the call is one thing; to screw it up after looking at video like this is grounds for losing your job.

INTosu.0

The second blown call was even worse. Ohio State set up — and made — a 49-yard field goal to go ahead 10-0 in the second quarter. Except, there was one problem — a full three seconds passed after the game clock hit zero before the ball was snapped. The five-yard penalty that should have ensued would have surely pushed Ohio State out of field goal range and forced a punt on 4th and 30.

I have only seen a missed playclock penalty once or twice, and it was only by less than a second each time. To allow a full three seconds extra is simply mind-boggling. The backline judge has literally one job before the ball is snapped after the teams are lined up and that’s to watch the playclock. It is the easiest job on the field. This is also why certain penalties should be reviewable.

O’Neill and Fiedler answered questions to a pool reporter after the game yesterday which was distributed to the media. The answers don’t make much sense, nor do the officials take any responsibility for screwing up calls that helped Ohio State score 10 of its 17 points.

Q: The Ohio State Interception in the first quarter, was there a problem with the two replay feeds on that?
O’Neill: The play technically was not thoroughly reviewed due to some technical difficulties with the equipment.

Q: In a case like that when the main feed and the back-up feed are not available, is there any provision that can you look at the in-house feed to get a back-up to get a look at that?
O’Neill: The feeds that the replay team looks at are the feeds you get at home. We can’t create our own rules. The replay rules are clear that we have to use the equipment provided. So, Tom (Fiedler) and the team reviewed what they had.

Q: Then there’s no provision to look at the in-house feed then?
O’Neill: Right.

Q: On Ohio State’s 49-yard field goal, there were some television replays that looked like the clock had run out and maybe two or three seconds had passed the zeros when the clock had run out. Was there any review of that?
O’Neill: No.

Q: Is that something that if you see it in the booth that you can buzz down or is that not a situation that is reviewable
Fiedler: That is not reviewable in terms of when the ball is snapped in relationship to the zeros on the clock.

******

Would these calls have affected the outcome of the game? Figuring that out is always the most frustrating part. The fact that Penn State fought valiantly and took the 13th best team in the country into overtime when nobody said they could is reason for optimism, and we should all be proud of this team. But thinking about what could have been — and what a win like this would have meant to the program — well, I should just stop watching that GIF over and over again.

******

UPDATE: As astute reader Jason points out, O’Neill’s explanation: “The feeds that the replay team looks at are the feeds you get at home. We can’t create our own rules. The replay rules are clear that we have to use the equipment provided. So, Tom (Fiedler) and the team reviewed what they had,” is just plain wrong. The crew could have used the in-house feed, which also showed a clear incompletion, to make the call.

Screen Shot 2014-10-26 at 3.11.25 PM

About the Author

Kevin Horne

Kevin Horne was the editor of Onward State from 2012-2014 and currently holds the position of Managing Editor Emeritus, which is a fake title he made up. He graduated from Penn State with degrees journalism and political science in 2014 and is currently seeking his J.D. at the Penn State Dickinson School of Law. A third generation Penn Stater from Williamsport, Pa., Kevin is also the president of the graduate student government. Email: [email protected]

Comments

More by Kevin

Hometown Brewery Releases Beer Honoring Evan Pugh

Penn State’s first president Evan Pugh was born in 1828 at Jordan Bank Farm, three miles south of the city center of Oxford, Pennsylvania, an hour west of Philadelphia in Chester County. One-hundred eighty-nine years later, an Oxford brewery is honoring one of the preeminent champions of “liberal and practical” higher education in the form of a delicious Porter.

Penn State Basketball Downs Colgate 72-59 In Front of Thanksgiving Eve Crowd

Why Honoring Paterno Still Matters

Athletics

Penn State Hockey Releases 2018-19 Roster

Brett Murray is no longer on the team after an uneventful tenure in Happy Valley that saw him score just one goal in 33 games.

Penn State Women’s Soccer Sophomores Start Season Strong

Penn State Women’s Soccer Beats Duquesne 6-0

Shea Moyer Lifts Penn State Women’s Soccer Past West Virginia 1-0

Penn State Women’s Soccer Poised For Strong 2018 Season

Student Life

Freshman 101: Helpful Links

Canvas, LionPATH, and eLiving are just a few of the websites you’ll need to figure out this great big world called Penn State.

Nominations Now Open For Gender-Neutral Homecoming Court

Your Fall 2018 Sylly Week Playlist

Plans Submitted For New KFC In State College

Developers have submitted preliminary land development plans to build a new KFC restaurant at 1780 S. Atherton St. in State College.

Mayor Don Hahn Plans To Veto Overnight Parking Restrictions In Highlands Neighborhood

Those in favor of the ordinance plan to consider overturning the veto at a special meeting next Monday.

While You Were Gone…

Here’s a roundup of what went on around Penn State during summer break.

Be the first to know

  • Top posts and the best Penn State stories

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

What Changed In State College While You Were Away

With another summer in the books, here are all the changes to State College that happened while you were gone.

Send this to a friend