Zach Hicks led the way with 22 points, six rebounds, four assists, and three steals with his 9-for-12 shooting from the field.
Moriah Murray and Gracie Merkle starred in the Lady Lions' opening win.
Penn State will await the NCAA tournament selection show.
Starck has earned the honor six times this season.
The game will not be shown on traditional cable, streaming exclusively on Peacock and in select IMAX theaters.
The Nittany Lions beat both Michigan and Iowa at Rec Hall this week to remain undefeated in conference play.