The Cavaliers' three-run fourth inning was too much for the Nittany Lions to overcome.
Dane Dowiak's two goals guided the Nittany Lions to win a close game in Columbus.
"Any team can beat any team on any given night, and it's super fun."
Goaltenders Liam Souliere and Kyle McClellan kept it a low-scoring and competitive matchup.
Schade and Berger have similar playing styles on the ice.
Berger broke his wrist during the Nittany Lions' 4-2 win over Michigan on Saturday.