Moriah Murray and Gracie Merkle starred in the Lady Lions' opening win.
Penn State will await the NCAA tournament selection show.
Starck has earned the honor six times this season.
The Nittany Lions beat both Michigan and Iowa at Rec Hall this week to remain undefeated in conference play.
Penn State was outplayed in the final regular season game and is unlikely to qualify for the Big Ten Tournament.
The Nittany Lions could not solve a familiar face in the loss.