The Nittany Lions were on a four-game skid going into Friday's game.
The Hobey Baker Memorial Award recognizes Division I men's hockey's best player.
Johnson totaled 13 points and seven rebounds in the Nittany Lions' most recent outing against Ohio State.
Lilley is averaging over nine minutes per game after only appearing in five games as a freshman.
Marisa became just the fifth Lady Lion ever to score 2,000 points.
The Nittany Lions completed a five-point comeback in the fourth set to upset the Buckeyes.