A disastrous first quarter led to the Lady Lions' first loss of the season.
Schlegel was named a semifinalist for the second time in her career on Wednesday.
Allie Holland and Kashauna Williams led the way with selections to the first-team.
With just seven games under her belt, freshman Shay Ciezki is already proving to be a valuable asset for Carolyn Kieger's squad.
The Nittany Lions couldn't complete the comeback against the Tigers.
The Nittany Lions move up one spot from No. 7 overall last week.