Kristin O'Neill and Brooke Hoss combined for seven goals in the losing effort.
After dropping the first set, Penn State won three straight sets as John Kerr led the way with 17 kills on 32 attacks, two aces, and recorded 21 total points.
The Nittany Lions rebounded with a win after a rough weekend at Illinois.
Brigham started all 35 games this past season for the Lady Lions.
The Nittany Lions have two series left before EIVA playoffs.
Makenna will compete under coach Cheryl Miller alongside nine other players.