After three gritty periods of regulation, neither team was able to get ahead as overtime expired.
For the second consecutive game, Penn State was absolutely blown out by its opponent.
The reason for the closure is currently unclear.
Pinegar will finish his five-year Penn State career as the all-time leader in extra points made.
The Spartans scored three unanswered goals to down the Nittany Lions in overtime.
The junior stepped into a full-time starting role at safety for the Nittany Lions in 2022.