Election officials attempted to upload the ballots in the first hours of Wednesday morning, but election software struggled to recognize the ballots.
The field hockey phenom claimed her fifth straight first team selection after a stellar season.
The threat was determined to be "non-credible."
Ayotte took around 53% of the vote with 89% of votes counted around 2 a.m. on Wednesday.
The wide receivers had just three catches for 49 yards against Ohio State.