PSU news by
Penn State's student blog



NCAA Files Motion to Dismiss PA’s Lawsuit

The NCAA filed a response to Pennsylvania’s lawsuit today, asking that the case be thrown out.

Governor Corbett filed the lawsuit on behalf of Pennsylvania on January 2, asking that a court to overturn the NCAA sanctions against Penn State. The lawsuit cites violation of anti-trust laws and a loss of financial benefits in the state of Pennsylvania as a reason for the court to rule.

The NCAA responded today, saying that Pennsylvania does not have grounds to sue the NCAA over an issue of discipline.

“This lawsuit is an inappropriate attempt to drag the federal courts into an intra-state political dispute,” the response states. “The remedial measures that Penn State agreed to were controversial, and have elicited strong feelings on all sides. Some think they are too harsh, and some think they are too lenient. But none of those feelings have anything to do with the antitrust laws.” identified these four reasons that the NCAA claims are reasons for dismissal:

  • The Complaint fails to state a claim because the ethical standards enforced by the NCAA are part of what makes college athletics unique and distinctive.
  • The NCAA’s regulation of college sports is subject to antitrust scrutiny only if it directly regulates economic activity, like television contracts or the salary of coaches.
  • The Complaint fails to allege harm to economic competition in the three (insufficiently pled) markets it identifies — for higher education, athletic apparel, and football recruits. The Complaint does not allege that lessened competition from Penn State has made it possible for other universities to raise tuition or the price of athletic apparel, or to reduce the number or quality of scholarships that they offer to student-athletes. Nor would such allegations be remotely plausible, given how large and robust these alleged nationwide markets would be. Plaintiff alleges only that PSU, a single competitor, might be athletically disadvantaged by the Consent Decree, but the antitrust laws protect competition, not competitors.
  • Plaintiff is not suing on behalf of anyone who has antitrust injury or standing to sue. PSU chose to compromise its differences with the NCAA by consent decree, and that choice was ratified by the appropriate decision-makers under Pennsylvania law.

You can read the 46-page response below:

NCAA motion to dismiss

About the Author

Kevin Horne

Kevin Horne was the editor of Onward State from 2012-2014 and currently holds the position of Managing Editor Emeritus, which is a fake title he made up. He graduated from Penn State with degrees journalism and political science in 2014 and is currently seeking his J.D. at the Penn State Dickinson School of Law. A third generation Penn Stater from Williamsport, Pa., Kevin is also the president of the graduate student government. Email: [email protected]


More by Kevin

Hometown Brewery Releases Beer Honoring Evan Pugh

Penn State’s first president Evan Pugh was born in 1828 at Jordan Bank Farm, three miles south of the city center of Oxford, Pennsylvania, an hour west of Philadelphia in Chester County. One-hundred eighty-nine years later, an Oxford brewery is honoring one of the preeminent champions of “liberal and practical” higher education in the form of a delicious Porter.

Penn State Basketball Downs Colgate 72-59 In Front of Thanksgiving Eve Crowd

Why Honoring Paterno Still Matters


Max Sauve Commits To Penn State Hockey

Sauve originally committed to Vermont in 2015, but flipped to Penn State at the eleventh hour and will join the Nittany Lions next season.

Penn State Women’s Volleyball Releases 2018 Schedule

Penn State Hoops Alumnus Joonas Suotamo’s Journey To Becoming Chewbacca Featured On ESPN’s ‘E:60’

Evaluating Tony Carr’s Performance At The 2018 NBA Draft Combine

Penn State Hockey Commit Evan Bell Wins Clark Cup With USHL’s Fargo Force

Student Life

10 Questions With 2019 Class Gift Director Tom Beeby

Tom Beeby will serve as the 2019 Class Gift Executive Director.

Career Services To Launch Integrated Career Management & Recruiting Platform

Penn State Esports Wins Tespa Collegiate Hearthstone Championship

Plans Submitted For New KFC In State College

Developers have submitted preliminary land development plans to build a new KFC restaurant at 1780 S. Atherton St. in State College.

Penn State Names Guadagnino Vice President For Administration

Guadagnino will continue to provide legal advice as associate general counsel in addition to his duties as vice president.

As Disciplinary Hearing Opens, Expert Says Baldwin Failed To Properly Represent Ex-Penn State Administrators

A Pennsylvania Disciplinary Board hearing began on Tuesday in Pittsburgh for former Penn State general counsel Cynthia Baldwin, who is accused of violating rules of professional conduct in her representation of former university administrators during the Jerry Sandusky investigation.

Be the first to know

  • Top posts and the best Penn State stories

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

10 Questions With 2019 Class Gift Director Tom Beeby

Tom Beeby will serve as the 2019 Class Gift Executive Director.

Send this to a friend