PSU news by
Penn State's student blog



Penn State Counterclaims Dismissed In Spanier Lawsuit

by Geoff Rushton

Penn State’s breach of contract claims against former university President Graham Spanier have been dismissed.

The university filed the counterclaims in Spanier’s own breach of contract suit against Penn State in December 2016. Last week, specially-presiding Judge Robert Eby dismissed all four of the university’s claims.

Eby’s opinion stated that the university waited too long to file its suit, with the statutes of limitations on the claims having expired, and that for some of Penn State’s claims, Spanier did not violate a 2010 employment contract and 2011 separation agreement.

Penn State had been seeking return of the money and benefits it paid Spanier since the separation agreement, as well as legal fees and interest, claiming he breached his employment contract and fiduciary duties and misled the university about the extent of his knowledge about the child sexual abuse investigation of Jerry Sandusky.

The separation agreement provided Spanier with 18 months salary, a $1.2 million retirement plan equivalency payment, a $700,000 payment during a one-year sabbatical, five years as a tenured faculty member at a salary of $600,000 a year and contributions to a retirement annuity.

Spanier, the school said, was obliged by his employment contract to act in good faith to the university’s interests, and before and during the negotiation of his separation agreement was obliged to disclose everything he knew about the investigation into Sandusky. Penn State would not have entered into the agreement had it known that Spanier had not fully disclosed all he knew.

Eby sustained Spanier’s objections that the breach of contract claim had passed the four-year statute of limitations.

Spanier was forced out as president in November 2011 following the charges against Sandusky and against former administrators Gary Schultz and Tim Curley for their handling and testimony about the 2001 incident reported by former football assistant Mike McQueary of seeing Sandusky with a boy in a locker room shower.

Spanier was charged in November 2012.

The university waited more than five years after Spanier’s termination and more than four years after he was charged in the case before making its claims. Spanier was convicted earlier this year of one misdemeanor count of endangering the welfare of a child and is appealing. Curley and Schultz pleaded guilty to the same charge.

Eby also wrote that Spanier’s fiduciary duties under his 2010 employment contract ended when he was terminated on Nov. 9, 2011 and that there is no language in the separation agreement to suggest otherwise. In fact, the university chose to bear the risk in the separation agreement of what more Spanier might know, Eby wrote.

“PSU’s argument that Spanier should have ‘confessed’ his involvement to the University is ludicrous,” Eby wrote. “Spanier had not yet been charged; it was folly for PSU to assume (and ridiculous for it to argue) that he would confess and invite criminal indictment before such indictment was inevitable.

“PSU could have protected itself; it could have insisted on a provision that provided it with an escape clause in the event that Spanier were ever implicated in the Sandusky cover up. It did not do so.”

Eby also noted that Penn State continued to meet its obligations under the separation agreement for years after Spanier was charged, waiving any claim to rescission of the agreement.

In Spanier’s lawsuit, Eby tossed most of the former president’s claims against Penn State in October 2016, but Spanier was allowed to file an amended complaint. Spanier claims Penn State violated a non-disparagement clause in his separation agreement, failed to reimburse him for legal fees and other expenses, and failed to provide administrative support once he moved to a faculty position.

About the Author

Posts from our partner website


More by

Herwig’s Austrian Bistro Sets Closing Date

Owner Bernd Brandstatter announced in March that restaurant would be closing between June and August, but the final day of business has been moved up.

Former Penn State Football Player Denies Burglary, Assault Accusations

Spats Cafe Collaboration With Allen Street Grill Set For Grand Opening


Reports: Tony Carr To Begin Professional Career In Italy

Tony Carr might have to wait a little longer than he had hoped to make his NBA debut.

Penn State Hockey’s Aarne Talvitie Showcases At Devils Development Camp

Penn State Hoops Releases 2018-19 Non-Conference Schedule

Forward Abdou Tsimbila Commits To Penn State Hoops

Penn State Volleyball Trio Representing U.S. At Pan-American Cup

Student Life

Penn State Student Dies Of Allergic Reaction To Peanuts

Max McGlinchey had just finished his freshman year studying finance.

Freshman 101: On-Campus Life

Student Farm To Commemorate Summer Solstice With Second Annual Celebration

Plans Submitted For New KFC In State College

Developers have submitted preliminary land development plans to build a new KFC restaurant at 1780 S. Atherton St. in State College.

Skeller Replacement Best We Could’ve Hoped For

The last thing we need is an Applebee’s, so maybe this is the best we could’ve hoped for, after all.

Playa Bowls To Open State College Location

Famous on the Jersey Shore for its brightly colored bowls and smoothies, Playa Bowls’ menu includes everything from açai and pitaya bowls to fresh juices.

Be the first to know

  • Top posts and the best Penn State stories

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Doggie’s Rathskeller And Garden Opens With Hopes Of Returning To Its Roots

The All-American Rathskeller is no more and Doggie’s Rathskeller and Garden is officially in business — opening with its “sneak peak” at the new bar Thursday afternoon in time for Arts Fest.

Send this to a friend