Topics

More

Onward State’s Blindfolded Ice Cream Taste Test

Every Penn Stater knows the Berkey Creamery boasts incredible ice cream, but nearly every townie would suggest Meyer Dairy serves up the superior scoops.

This week, our staff set out to settle the debate…objectively. Blindfolded, we taste-tested five staple flavors from the Creamery and Meyer Dairy to determine whose ice cream ranks supreme.

So, are Creamery lines really worth the wait? Does Meyer Dairy deserve more clout than it gets? See what our staff thought below.

Your ad blocker is on.

Please choose an option below.

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter:
OR
Support quality journalism:
Purchase a Subscription!

About the Author

Hailey Stutzman

Hailey was Onward State's visual editor, as well as the co-host and editor of our podcast, Podward State.

How To Donate To THON 2026 This Weekend

Get those donations in!

Luke Misa Adjusting To Expanded Role For Penn State Men’s Hockey

“Guys are gonna have to step up, that’s just how it is.”

Penn State Wrestling’s Rocco Welsh Reflects On High-Stakes Clash With Former Team

“I had some thoughts about going against my former team, but I tried to act like it was the same as any other match.”

113kFollowers
67.7kFollowers
4,570Subscribers
Sign up for our Newsletter
Other posts by Hailey

Make This Place Your Home: Hailey Stutzman’s Senior Column

“Although I lived in a new place every single year, each one became home in its own way, thanks to the people, the memories, and everything in between.”

[Photo Story] 46 Of Our Favorite Photos From THON 2025

[Photo Story] The Best Photos From Day One Of THON 2025