Penn State-Themed Crumbl Cookie Flavors

Crumbl Cookies, a fast-growing cookie store chain with a rotating menu, recently opened up its first State College location. Crumbl’s menu of more than 200 cookie flavors changes weekly and features everything from the classic chocolate chip to more obscure flavors like cornbread or caramel popcorn.

Since the bakery is new to Happy Valley, we wanted to offer a few Penn State-themed flavors that the cookie joint could add to its growing arsenal of cookies.

Grilled Stickies

Arguably the best creamery flavor, the iconic Grilled Stickies is the first option we could think of. Just imagine yourself biting into a warm cinnamon-flavored cookie with a slightly crunchy cinnamon sugar coating on it, but it’s soft and gooey on the inside. These flavors are about to get pretty ~out there,~ but honestly, a Grilled Stickies-flavored cookie sounds absolutely gas.

Champs Dirty Sprite

If Bert Kreischer likes Dirty Sprites, why not make them into a cookie? Now, I might ditch the alcohol from the cookie recipe because Crumbl is on the family-friendly side, but even without the party juice, it would be a great cookie. Also, just imagine the color. You could even drop a little Champs logo on top of each one.

Grilled Chicken Thigh Halal

It’s a staple in the campus dining lineup, so why can’t it be a staple in the Crumbl Cookie lineup? If you thought you’ve had enough grilled chicken thigh halal, think again. This cookie is going to blow your feathers away!

The Floor Of A Cocktagon

This one is for the boys. You know how when you enter a cocktagon to release a fat piss and step in a little bit of liquid on the floor and try to convince yourself it’s water…but the forecast is nothing but blue skies? Clearly, you stepped in another man’s urine. Okay — now take that feeling, and turn it into a cookie! Sure, it’s probably not the best-tasting cookie, but it would definitely be unique.

Irving’s Chai Milkshake

This is more of a personal opinion, but the Irving’s Chai Milkshake is one of the best things State College has to offer. Personally, we haven’t seen a Chai Milkshake-flavored cookie but think that it would be delightful.

Freshly Cut Old Main Grass

Mhmmmm… It’s a Tuesday morning and bright and sunny out. Campus smells like cow manure, and OPP is out cutting the grass. You walk across Old Main and get a sniff of that freshly cut green stuff. You think to yourself, “this would make a great cookie flavor.” We aren’t saying that the cookie needs to taste like grass, but maybe it gives you the same feeling as freshly-cut Old Main grass. Feelings of comfort, hope, and accomplishment come with a nicely mowed lawn.

Bagel Crust Bacon Egg and Cheese

This one goes out to all the New York and New Jersey folks. We aren’t completely sure how this one will turn out, but we’re thinking it would be a bagel cookie base and have cheesy egg icing with little pieces of bacon on top. We are just proposing ideas here. It is up to the master Crumbl bakers to figure out how to make them work.

Finals Week

Stick with us here. It’s Tuesday of finals week. You have two massive exams tomorrow. You want to treat yourself for the hard work you’ve been doing but want to keep on grinding. So, you decide to do both by munching on a Crumbl finals week-flavored cookie. What makes it finals week-flavored? Well, it is a coffee-flavored cookie with Adderall-infused frosting. Yum! Now, you can enjoy a delicious, warm cookie while staying on task.

Special thank you to Crumbl for providing us with some stock images of its cookies that we used to photoshop our Penn State flavors.

Your ad blocker is on.

Please choose an option below.

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter:
Support quality journalism:
Purchase a Subscription!

About the Author

Rico Gore

Rico is a senior advertising major from Pittsburgh who has been with Onward State since just a couple weeks into his freshman year. He loves to drink Diet Coke and eat Mexican food. You can follow Rico on Instagram @RealBigRico and TikTok @RealBigRico.

Penn State Board Of Trustees Approves 2025-26 Fiscal Budget

The budget features increases between 1-4% for tuition, housing, and food for most students.

OS Reviews: Penn State In College Football 25

Whether our staffers loved playing in Beaver Stadium or beating Ohio State, here’s how they found the newest EA Sports game.

Reintroducing Onward State’s Penn State Football Student Ticket Exchange

Whether you’re trying to offload a ticket you don’t want or making sure you get to sit with your friends, Onward State’s ticket exchange is here to help.