‘I Wrestle In The Way I’d Want To Watch’: Penn State Wrestling’s Mitchell Mesenbrink Adjusting To Life At New Weight

When Penn State wrestler Mitchell Mesenbrink stepped off the mat at the NCAA National Championships in March, he thought it might’ve been the final time.
It was a dominant win via technical fall over Iowa’s Mikey Caliendo, and it clinched him his second national championship. Despite winning the Hodge Trophy a few weeks later on the back of a historically dominant season, he encountered something that many elite athletes deal with.
He wanted to feel joy in what he did.
“I think that goes into ‘Why am I doing this?’ I stepped off the mat last year, not knowing if I was going to compete again,” Mesenbrink said in a media availability Tuesday. “For me, it was like, anything that I’m going to do, first, I want to do it, and I want to have joy in that, and two, I want it to be on my terms.”
That indecisiveness likely led Mesenbrink to sit out of all freestyle competitions in the offseason. After winning a U23 world title in 2025 and going into this cycle as a leading candidate to represent the United States at the Senior World Championships at 74 kilograms, he simply didn’t compete.
“You’ve heard the whole quote: ‘If you love something, let it go, and if it’s love, it’ll come back,'” he said. “That’s kind of like with wrestling.”
Heading into this season, it still wasn’t a sure thing he’d be out there.
The fight to get Levi Haines a fifth year of eligibility and the logjam of talent shouldn’t have kept the best pound-for-pound wrestler in the country out, but he was willing to do it.
“If there’s a chance that I don’t wrestle and Levi gets to go in there, well then I would love to help him,” he said when asked about the uncertainty. “If it’s the opposite, which it’s looking like it’s going to be, then I’m in there, and I’m very lucky to have the support of Penn State and the Penn State staff and to enjoy it.”
Wrestling has been a big part of the Wisconsin native’s life for a long time, but there’s a distinct difference between living the sport and competing in the sport.
Despite being one of the best in the world at what he does, Mesenbrink doesn’t watch much wrestling on his own. When asked about his teammate, PJ Duke, competing at his old weight class at the NWCA All-Star Classic next Tuesday, he was completely unaware of the event’s details or Duke’s opponent.
“I don’t really watch much wrestling, so I don’t know many people in the sport other than my teammates,” he added.
It’s inconceivable to some that someone so great could seem so apathetic about his sport, but Mesenbrink sees it simply. In a sport that’s recently seen quarrels over a lack of aggressiveness and risk-taking, doing the opposite has become his distinct style.
“Just growing up, I really wanted to watch exciting wrestling, hence why I love Penn State so much,” Mesenbrink said. “The fact of the matter is that it’s not how wrestling goes a lot of the time, especially when it’s even matchups. I don’t think a lot of wrestlers are willing to do the things necessary in terms of taking the risks that come with being able to put yourself ahead or make the match exciting.”
Mesenbrink’s off-mat personality centers on his love for music. His social media feeds are tailored towards surfing and the beach.
He’s also starring in a biopic about legendary wrestler Dan Gable in the near future.
When he’s on the mat, though? He wrestles the way he wishes the sport would be, serving as a foil to those one-takedown overtime matches that every top-10 bout seems to be now.
“I wrestle in the way in which I’d want to watch,” Mesenbrink said. “I’m not just saying ‘Oh, I don’t watch wrestling because it’s boring’, because that sounds ridiculous, but I want to watch things that are exciting. A lot of the time, statistically speaking, you’re going to find a lot more matches of like ‘Wow, that was tough to watch.”
He’ll be taking that unique and exciting style of wrestling to a new weight class, giving him a challenge after winning 50 consecutive matches at his previous weight of 165 pounds and going undefeated in back-to-back seasons.
While nine pounds might not seem like much, going up a weight means you’ll inevitably be wrestling stronger guys who are harder to score on. That’s a challenge Mesenbrink is taking in stride.
“You got guys going up as I did, you got guys that have been there, and you got guys that are coming down [from 184 pounds], so I think it’s sweet,” he said. “At the end of the day, we all got to weigh in at 174, and then two hours later we wrestle.”
The start to his season has been the status quo for him over the years. After dealing with the strength differences early in both matches, he’s rebounded to defeat both Bloomsburg’s Mohamed Abdelhady and Oklahoma’s Ty Eise by tech fall, continuing an incredible streak of bonus-point victories.
In his 53-match winning streak dating back to his lone career loss at the 2024 NCAA National Championships, Mesenbrink has nine pins or forfeits, 31 tech falls, nine major decisions, and only four wins by decision.
It’s a level of dominance you only see once in a generation.
The only thing that can stop him? Wearing a singlet that’s too baggy, something that’s gained attention in college wrestling circles. Fortunately for everyone, it’ll be toned down going forward.
“I definitely could’ve scored five [more] times if my singlet wasn’t as baggy, so we’re definitely bringing it a size down, maybe two,” Mesenbrink said. “Because I’d rather get takedowns than have a baggy singlet.”
All eight of his career pins came last season, and while it might be harder to do early on against stronger wrestlers, it’s only a matter of time before they start coming in droves.
“He’s going to have to adjust to figure out how to pin a bigger wrestler, but he’s looking really good,” head coach Cael Sanderson said. “He’s figuring out how to wrestle at 174, and he’ll get stronger throughout the year.”
There’s a sense of enjoying something while you’ve had it, and Penn State wrestling fans should certainly do that with the redshirt senior in his final year.
In a long line of dominant Nittany Lions, appreciate it when you’ve got something truly special.
“This is my last year in college wrestling,” Mesenbrink said. “I want it to be what I want it to be.”
Your ad blocker is on.
Please choose an option below.
Purchase a Subscription!



