Despite almost allowing a reverse sweep, the Nittany Lions rallied to earn their first EIVA victory of the season.
Henchy returns to his home state of California.
Stoll marks Penn State's fourth Super Bowl-winning player in consecutive seasons.
A crushing fielding error in the bottom of the seventh handed Penn State its first loss of the season.
A clean injury report and a week of rest could serve as a second wind for the Lady Lions at the tail end of the regular season.
"This is exactly why we bring these teams out here in January. We want to test ourselves against the best."