While the two programs share similar stories of outside disbelief, the squads also have comparable pieces that could lead to the same storybook ending.
Penn State won six of its first eight games against Ohio State, but Urban Meyer's recent run has shifted the rivalry's balance.
The Block O, the Buckeyes' student section, tweeted Tuesday for fans to "#BlackoutTheShoe."
The cover is part of a commemorative issue for Penn State's 25 years in the Big Ten.
Saquon Barkley, Trace McSorley, Marcus Allen, Grant Haley, and Jason Cabinda all received honors for their standout performances against Michigan last Saturday.
For the eighth time, College GameDay will broadcast from the site of Penn State vs. Ohio State this weekend. Not all of the first seven matchups have fallen in Penn State's favor.