Seth Lundy led Penn State with 20 points, but his efforts weren't enough to take down the Scarlet Knights on their Senior Day.
Penn State had another exceptional showing, as five wrestlers will try to become Big Ten Champions Sunday.
A late goal from Ryan Kirwan helped Penn State force a game three against the Buckeyes.
Despite three goals and one assist from Mark Sickler and 11 saves by goalie Aleric Fyock, the Nittany Lions couldn't recover after a Quaker goal in the final seconds of the tight matchup.
After a successful first session, Penn State will have seven wrestlers in Saturday's semifinals.
Penn State couldn't keep up with Loyola Maryland in the two teams' first matchup since 2020.