Fans can vote for the award until 6 p.m. on Friday, March 24.
Nevills, a senior heavyweight wrestler, posted a 2-0 record this past season.
Aaron Brooks and Carter Starocci both secured their third-career national championships.
Shayne Van Ness, Beau Bartlett, and Max Dean kept the momentum going for the Nittany Lions during session five of the NCAA Championships.
The Nittany Lions clinched their 11th national championship –– and their 10th in the last 12 years.
Levi Haines and Greg Kerkvliet will join veterans Roman Bravo-Young, Carter Starocci, and Aaron Brooks in the NCAA National Championships finals.