It’s no secret that fans want #GameDayPSU in Happy Valley next weekend for the White Out game against Michigan. As long as the Wolverines can beat Indiana next week, there’s not a better matchup for the GameDay crew to come and visit — unless you count USC-Notre Dame, which we’ll admit clocks in at a close second.
If GameDay makes the right decision and heads to State College this month, it would mark the sixth time the show has visited Happy Valley since 1997. The first five times the GameDay crew visited Penn State include thrilling victories, but also a pair of crushing defeats for the Nittany Lions.
Here’s a breakdown of how those five games went for Penn State football:
November 8, 1997: No. 4 Michigan vs. No. 3 Penn State
An already wet and miserable day quickly became much worse for Penn State fans following Michigan’s beat down of Joe Paterno’s previously undefeated Nittany Lion squad. The Wolverines outplayed Penn State in all three phases of the game en route to a convincing 34-8 victory on the day.
The game marked the worst loss by a Paterno-led team in 32 years and the biggest margin of defeat suffered at home by Penn State since 1931. It helped vault Michigan to the No. 1 spot in the final polls of the season.
Hopefully the matchup next Saturday has a happier ending for Nittany Lion fans.
August 28, 1999: No. 4 Arizona vs. No. 3 Penn State
A rare high profile out-of-conference game brought the GameDay crew back to State College in 1999 for the Pigskin Classic. This time, however, Penn State would fair much better against a top-five opponent.
From the opening kickoff, the Nittany Lions dominated Arizona, soundly defeating the Wildcats 41-7. Penn State’s offense racked up 504 total yards, while the defense held Arizona to only 356 yards and did not relinquish the shutout until there were only 47 seconds left in the game.
A marquee matchup-turned-blowout was probably best summed up after the game by Paterno when he said, “I don’t think this ball game proves anything.”
Here are a few highlights from the contest (We cut to Lee Corso’s headgear selection for you):
October 8, 2005: No. 6 Ohio State vs. No. 16 Penn State
Following a miserable 2004 season that saw Penn State go 4-7 without earning bowl eligibility, fans were beginning to wonder whether or not it was time for the great Joe Paterno to retire. Instead, the 2005 Nittany Lions came out of the gates swinging, winning their first six games to set up a top-25 matchup with the Buckeyes.
In a game that proved Paterno was still a coach capable of leading a team back to the top of the Big Ten, the Nittany Lions bottled up Ohio State quarterback Troy Smith, holding the dual threat passer to only 154 total yards. On offense, quarterback Michael Robinson and receiver Derrick Williams led the way to a dramatic 17-10 victory for Penn State. This game also produced one of the most iconic Penn State moments of the past few decades: “The Fumble.”
The win helped propel the Nittany Lions to a share of the Big Ten title, and an appearance in the Orange Bowl that season.
October 27, 2007: No. 1 Ohio State vs. No. 25 Penn State
Once again Gameday came back for a match up between the Nittany Lions and the Buckeyes. This time, however, Ohio State got the better of Penn State, comfortably winning 37-17.
Penn State quarterback Anthony Morelli was largely ineffective, only throwing for 111 yards, no touchdowns, and an interception. On defense, the Nittany Lions were gashed for 200 yards on the ground and surrendered a further 253 through the air on a night when they were completely outmatched against the Buckeyes.
The loss dropped Penn State out of the top 25 rankings for the remainder of the season.
September 26, 2009 Iowa vs. No. 4 Penn State
A heartbreaking loss to Iowa at Kinnick Stadium the previous season cost Penn State a shot at a national title. A year later, with revenge on their mind and on their own turf, the Nittany Lions…laid another dud against the Hawkeyes.
Penn State quarterback Daryll Clark played the worst game of his career, only completing 12 of his 32 pass attempts for only 198 yards, a single touchdown, and a back-breaking three interceptions. The defense held its own against the Iowa offense, but ultimately the Nittany Lions’ four turnovers proved too much to overcome in a 21-10 defeat at the hands of the Hawkeyes.
The loss derailed Penn State’s early season National Championship hopes. At least this year, the Nittany Lions were able to escape a game against Iowa unscathed.
Keep on promoting #GameDayPSU to get Lee, Kirk, Desmond, and the gang to come to Happy Valley.