PSU news by
Penn State's student blog



Letter Questions Pfister’s Piece

On Monday, the Collegian published a column by Ryan Pfister arguing that the University Park Allocation Committee (UPAC) was still the best option for distributing the money collected through the $74 fee students pay each semester (the Student Activities Fee).

The beauty of UPAC is that it’s organized around rules, rather than people. UPAC doesn’t put all the requests on the table and decide which ones it likes best.

Instead, it funds on a first-come, first-serve basis. Requests that fulfill the funding guidelines get money. Those that don’t, do not. And since UPAC designates specifically what the student activity fee money will be used for, the potential for misuse and waste is minimal.

He also cites some extravagant expenditures by UPUA last year.

Pfister was prompted to write the column by the news that The LION 90.7fm and UPUA were trying to secure a guaranteed source of funding, so that they didn’t have to petition UPAC every year. Pfister effectively says that he doesn’t trust students in general to not waste the money (he does note that he doesn’t think this year’s UPUA board would do that).

His distrust is compounded by his legitimate criticism of Penn State’s student government, namely the low election turn out. (Last year, Gavin and Valerie won with 2,217 of the 4,457 votes cast. That’s only 12.2% of the Penn State undergraduate student body.) He thinks this reduces accountability for student leaders.

Thomas Shakely, president of The LION 90.7fm, responded to Pfister’s column in a Letter to the Editor today. In it, he makes the argument that the Collegian is already enjoying the kind of guaranteed funding that The LION and UPUA are petitioning for.

Shakely raises a very interesting point. Is the Collegian funded by the University or not?

The Daily Collegian, though, is the only of these three central student groups that receives annual, guaranteed funding, to the tune of tens of thousands of dollars for daily subscriptions to the paper, from the university. If the student newspaper requires a guaranteed annual subsidy from the university to serve its mission, is it so absurd that the student radio station and student government require similar independence?

What would happen if the University no longer “subscribed” to the Collegian? How many students do you know who would be willing to pay 50¢ or 25¢ every day for the paper? Though the Collegian’s Editor-in-Chief is not under President Spanier’s jurisdiction, the Collegian could be financially suffocated if Spanier were to cancel Penn State’s massive subscription. In that sense, the Collegian is not independent.

Don’t get me wrong, that would be a bad situation. The Collegian provides an essential service for the Penn State community. I read it every day, and so does a large percentage of the undergraduate student body. But that’s the very point of Shakely’s letter– The LION and UPUA also provide essential services to the Penn State community. He’s not arguing that the Collegian should not receive annual funding, but rather that The LION and UPUA should enjoy that same privilege.

On a related note, Chris Morrel, the Executive Director of Safeguard Old State, argues that UPAC should be merged somehow with UPUA. He says that UPAC is flawed because its members are not elected. While I agree with his desire for a more enlightened system for distributing the SAF, I don’t believe that UPUA is the right organization to execute it. It would be easy to convert UPAC to an elected position.

A guaranteed allocation for the Collegian through the University’s subscription and for The LION and UPUA through UPAC or some other organization seems to be a very good idea. Let’s figure out a way to achieve both criteria, so that these organizations have guranteed funding and transparent budgets.

About the Author


Creator of @OnwardState. Big fan of sweaters.


State College Links
More by Davis

Penn State and the Process of Life

To paraphrase Mark Twain: The reports of higher education’s death have been an exaggeration. American universities produce more research and relevant knowledge for the world at large than any other institutions I know of. Tuition may be too damn high, but over the long-run, undergraduate degrees are definitely worth the cost. But Penn State could be so much more. It used to be, I think.

Bonded in Blue, White, and Worry

43 Simmons


Big Ten Announces 2018-2019 In-Conference Hoops Matchups

The 2018-2019 season will feature a 20-game in conference schedule for the first time.

From Manager To Walk On: Penn State Softball’s Ashton Mensinger Enjoying Unexpected Opportunity

Penn State Women’s Lacrosse Loses To Maryland 13-8

Penn State Men’s Lacrosse’s Ryan Keenan Selected In MLL Draft

Penn State Baseball Snaps Eleven-Game Losing Streak Against Mount St. Mary’s

Student Life

Miniature Penn State Tailgate Bus Up For Sale, Tailgate Never Has To End

The bus was purchased at a church and designed to carry 22 children. Now it carries about 30 cases of beer.

Creamery ‘Brew And White’ Iced Coffee Now Available

Be A Part Of The 2018 Senior Class Photo Inside Beaver Stadium

Saquon Barkley Shows Some Skin On SI Cover

The NFL Draft begins Thursday, April 26, at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas. Barkley is expected to be a top-five pick, and he and his most vehement supporters say there’s no reason he won’t go No. 1 overall.

Blue-White 2018 Prop Bets

Step right up and place some bets, folks!

Dry Weather Expected For Blue-White Weekend

Predicted temperatures in the mid-50s and mostly cloudy skies should make for a pleasant (but more importantly, dry) Blue-White Weekend.

Be the first to know

  • Top posts and the best Penn State stories

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Miniature Penn State Tailgate Bus Up For Sale, Tailgate Never Has To End

The bus was purchased at a church and designed to carry 22 children. Now it carries about 30 cases of beer.

Send this to a friend