PSU news by
Penn State's student blog

Topics

About

iClick, You Click…

Love them or loathe them–and for most students, the latter applies–clickers are an integral part of large-size lecture halls that most Penn State students experience at some point in their academic career.

At one point or another, almost every student–even those who never use a clicker–will question the implementation, usage, and even necessity of these hated devices. They’re expensive and clunky, but worst of all, their purpose is so simple that they seem unnecessary. Surely a simpler and cheaper solution exists, right?

In order to find out what really makes these devices click, I spoke with Group Leader for Technology Classroom Support, the man behind the selection of the iClicker system, David Test.

I want to thank Mr. Test for being incredibly transparent and sharing every detail that he was able to share with me regarding the evaluation process for the clicker systems at Penn State.

While many, myself included, might have initially believed that the student bookstore was the decision-maker for the clicker systems used across campus, the mastermind behind the evaluation and selection process for the system is really Penn State’s Information Technology Services, according to Mr. Test.

When the previous clicker product had reach its end-of-life, ITS started a pilot program to evaluate current clicker solutions and selected two possibilities. After this selection, they ran the pilot in the spring ’11 semester in which 1400 students used a competitors product and 1400 students used the iClicker product. Student and instructor feedback heavily favored the iClicker system, and so the decision was made to move forward to implement this device.

In addition, Mr. Test mentioned that ITS interviewed almost every instructor that has used a clicker in class or lecture since 2004 as another base for selection.

As mentioned, these clickers don’t come cheap. At The Student Bookstore on College Avenue, a new clicker will cost $37.50 and to rent one for the semester will run $17.95.  That seems a bit steep for a device that simply records attendance or allows students to answer a poll question, so I asked Mr. Test if there were cheaper options that ITS evaluated.

ITS evaluated and continues to monitor and review online polling systems to replace a physical clicker system, but the biggest roadblock to this option is that currently the wireless systems in Penn State classrooms aren’t capable of handing the simultaneous traffic that a lecture hall such as 100 Thomas would create.

In addition, not all online solutions are free, and because these solutions are run via web or mobile, there are a “never-ending list of failure points.”

As wireless support in classrooms across the university improve, ITS will continue to evaluate online and mobile options on a semester-by-semester basis, but Mr. Test says their implementation won’t be in the near future.

As for Penn State’s contract with iClicker, the university has a 5-year contract that extends only to the University Park campus in which the university will offer iClicker as the sole ITS-supported clicker system on campus. Professors are free to choose other systems, but ITS will only provide technical support for iClicker systems and hardware.

From what I can tell, though we may hate the dreaded clickers and the high cost to purchase or rent one, it appears as if they’re the best option in terms of functionality and usability in the classroom at this point in time. Hopefully in the future the classroom wireless network will be able to support the bandwidth that would result from simultaneous mobile and web action in a large class

If you have any clicker horror stories, or just a thought one way or the other about the use of clickers at Penn State, leave a comment below.

About the Author

Comments

More by Jason

College Christmas/Hanukkah Gift Guide

As the proverbial “broke college students,” I can say with a fair level of confidence that the majority of you won’t be spending a fortune on Christmas presents this year. But, presents for family do not have to break the bank. If you haven’t yet purchased any gifts, check out some suggestions for last-minute shopping that can be light on your wallet.

Class Gift Chosen: Lion Shrine Historical Display

Onward Debates: Why “Occupying” Should End

Athletics

Longtime Lady Lions Coach Rene Portland Dies Of Cancer

Portland brought Penn State women’s basketball to national prominence during her 27-year coaching tenure.

Penn State Hoops Gets Iced Up For NIT Title

Reports: Tony Carr To Begin Professional Career In Italy

Penn State Hockey’s Aarne Talvitie Showcases At Devils Development Camp

Penn State Hoops Releases 2018-19 Non-Conference Schedule

Student Life

Penn State Student Dies Of Allergic Reaction To Peanuts

Max McGlinchey had just finished his freshman year studying finance.

Freshman 101: On-Campus Life

Student Farm To Commemorate Summer Solstice With Second Annual Celebration

Plans Submitted For New KFC In State College

Developers have submitted preliminary land development plans to build a new KFC restaurant at 1780 S. Atherton St. in State College.

‘Rathskeller’ Name Subject Of Trademark Infringement Lawsuit

The complaint cites that the business has been sold throughout the years and is not tied to that specific location.

Finance Committee Recommends Tuition Freeze For In-State Undergraduate Students

If it is approved by a full-Board vote Friday, the committee’s budget plan will freeze in-state undergraduate tuition for the first time since 2015.

Be the first to know

  • Top posts and the best Penn State stories

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Penn State Hoops Gets Iced Up For NIT Title

A banner raising ceremony will commemorate the achievement prior to the team’s season opener on November 9 against North Florida.

Send this to a friend