Topics

More

Penn State Football Hot Takes Post-Minnesota

 

Bowl season.

Penn State football clinched bowl eligibility with a 42-14 beatdown of Minnesota on Saturday night. The Golden Gophers didn’t get to State College until around noon on gameday, but it didn’t seem to matter anyway.

Carson Hansen rushed for 126 yards and a touchdown in his best game as a Nittany Lion, while the Penn State defense suffocated Minnesota for all four quarters. It was a stark second-half improvement for Penn State as a whole after it almost blew a 22-point lead to Washington.

The Nittany Lions’ most well-rounded win of the season came with some interesting takes on social media throughout the weekend.

Here’s how our football beat reacted to some of them.

Penn State Should Start Alex Manske At Quarterback Against Maryland

Cadyn Gill: I am begging. Please, no more Alex Manske talk in 2026.

It was cool to see him throw his first collegiate touchdown pass in garbage time against Minnesota, but that’s where it needs to end, barring an injury to Rocco Becht.

Penn State’s starter steered the team into the storm that was a four-game skid, and more importantly, got the Nittany Lions out of it with a chance to win five straight games to close out the season.

And not to get ahead of ourselves, but I’d bet money Penn State’s 2027 starting quarterback isn’t on the roster right now. Sorry to all the Manske fanboys out there, but I’m not buying the whole see what we have for next season idea.

Quite frankly, neither Matt Campbell nor Becht can afford to squander the chance to win out and right four straight weeks of wrongs, and that now includes a bowl game. Becht needs to play out the rest of his final collegiate season and put his stamp on such a gritty opening chapter of the Campbell era.

Jamie Lynch: No, but I think the more intriguing question would be whether Manske should be Penn State’s starting quarterback in 2027.

This is Becht’s team, and he deserves to finish the season as the signal caller. Penn State doesn’t need to win out, per se, but it would help the program’s future. Manske should certainly get more snaps with two weaker opponents coming up, but the Nittany Lions should focus on finishing the year on the right foot.

As I alluded to, these next handful of weeks will be critical in analyzing Manske’s potential. Offensive coordinator Taylor Mouser once called him “one of the most talented guys on the offense,” so it would be interesting to see whether that shows up in his play.

Whatever the case, Campbell will need to target a quarterback in the portal regardless. Competition is always a good thing.

Oscar Orellana: Manske threw his first collegiate touchdown pass with an absolute dime to James Peoples late in the fourth quarter against the Golden Gophers.

While it was a sweet moment for Manske, given the health issues he went through in the offseason, it came exactly when it needed to: garbage time.

Becht has proven why he’s firmly Penn State’s starting quarterback through this three-game win streak, and it’s clear why Campbell has continuously held him in high regard even at his lowest. It would be a disservice to Becht to bench him just to see what Manske can do in the final stretch.

I even saw a few people say Manske should start against Rutgers, which is one of the worst things I’ve ever read. It’s Senior Day for Becht, who has ridden with Campbell for years.

Manske is a feel-good story, and he will definitely get more reps if Penn State puts away the Scarlet Knights and Terrapins early, as it should, but Becht deserves to end the season with the keys to the offense. No ifs, ands, or buts about it.

Penn State Doesn’t Deserve To Be Bowl Eligible

Cadyn Gill: The Nittany Lions have six wins. Why would they not deserve to play in a bowl game?

Let’s leave the strength-of-schedule policing for just the College Football Playoff Selection Committee, please and thank you.

But while we’re at it, I’d actually argue Penn State is one of the most deserving teams to be bowl-eligible. It was once questioned whether the blue and white would even win a Big Ten game in 2026, and now the Nittany Lions have the chance to win five in a row to close out the season.

Not to be a revisionist, but Penn State is a handful of plays away from being an 8-2 team with only losses to USC and Northwestern.

Respect Campbell and the Nittany Lions.

Jamie Lynch: I’ve never been a big fan of the word “deserves” in the world of sports. If you win six games, you deserve to be bowl-eligible. It’s as simple as that, so I’ll leave it at that.

Oscar Orellana: This is total nonsense. The Nittany Lions took their horrendous four-game losing streak, reviewed everything over the bye week, and have been a completely different team since taking the field against Purdue.

It doesn’t matter what happened before. The Penn State team that showed up against Minnesota looked like one of the best the Big Ten has to offer.

While the consistency hasn’t been there, it’s impressive how this group has made strides and clinched bowl eligibility with two games to spare.

Miss me with this take. Airball opinion.

The Running Back Unit Is The Most Improved Over The Season

Cadyn Gill: You can point to a lot of offensive units taking massive strides in the second half of the season.

The offensive line, receivers (really just Chase Sowell), and, of course, running backs.

But Hansen and Cam Wallace have certainly flipped a switch since the bye week, combining for 614 yards and five touchdowns in the last three games.

Hansen, in particular, has noticeably improved his contact balance, as he showed on his long touchdown against the Golden Gophers, breaking four tackles en route to the end zone. That development in itself has been impressive to witness, because his inability to stay on his feet was a massive issue in the first chunk of games.

Jamie Lynch: Undoubtedly. It’s been night and day.

The ground game flipped the switch when the offensive line improved, but globally, the running back group probably deserves the most credit for its turnaround.

Hansen looks like a completely different animal than the first half of the season. He’s breaking tackles he wasn’t previously breaking, racking up rushes of more than 20 yards. Before the Purdue game, he had exactly zero runs that fell into that category.

Wallace has excelled too, giving Penn State the home-run threat it desperately needed. It took the coaching staff a while to identify which players could be the difference makers, but the sky has been the limit since the top two guys emerged.

The Nittany Lions have typically found success as a program when they prioritized establishing a run game, and it certainly seems like that trend will continue.

Oscar Orellana: Penn State fans audibly groaned every time the Nittany Lions pounded the rock in the opening six games of the year. It was just not a good situation, with little to no tangible improvement available.

What Hansen and Wallace have done since the bye week is nothing short of a miracle. Sure, the offensive line has performed miles better, but those two have seized every opportunity and made this Penn State rushing attack a genuine problem heading into the end of the season.

Penn State fans will look back kindly on this group because of their stark improvement.

Penn State Still Lacks An Identity

Cadyn Gill: I mean, 41, 37, and 51 rush attempts in the last three weeks speak for themselves.

After the Washington win, Campbell emphasized the need to play strong defense and run the football effectively. The complementary combo is elastic, meaning it can win games in all sorts of contexts, including injuries, hostile road environments, or unforgiving weather.

It’s clear that’s what he and the team have focused on since the bye week, and three straight wins make it hard to argue Penn State hasn’t executed it.

Jamie Lynch: I think Penn State’s identity has really begun to take shape over the last three weeks.

I’ll start by saying this: the 2016 team was in the house on Saturday, and it reminded me how polar-opposite the 2026 squad is from the former group’s reputation as a second-half team.

It seems like the Nittany Lions are best off when they pile on points in the opening 30 minutes and spend the next half-hour praying that it’s a big enough cushion.

It’s become increasingly evident that this team is built around a strong run game, but a talented wide receiver in Sowell and two reliable tight ends have given Penn State an extra dimension to the offense.

On defense, the Nittany Lions boast one of the nation’s top secondaries.

As Becht said it best after the Minnesota game, “It’s a brand of football that you want to play.”

Oscar Orellana: Totally untrue. This team’s identity has shifted to quick starts, long drives, and elite pass defense. The Washington win was huge for Campbell’s culture going forward.

The run-heavy mentality has meshed well in recent weeks, while the defense has continued to do its job on the back end. Penn State is focused on sustainable possession and converting in the red zone, which it failed to do in its first run of games.

Campbell’s game management, on the other hand? It still needs a bit of work, but the last few rolls of tape have helped him start to formulate a signature style of play in Happy Valley.

Carson Hansen Would Have Been The Big Ten’s Top Running Back If The Offensive Line Performed At This Level To Open Conference Play

Cadyn Gill: I want to be clear. Hansen was just as much of a problem as the offensive line was at the start of the season.

The running back appeared slow, indecisive, and unable to fight through contact.

But it’s clear from talking with the players and coaches that the offense needed to consolidate, allowing for fast-thinking, physical execution of Mouser’s play calls.

Since then, Hansen has been a great runner. Still, he sits at No. 11 in Big Ten rushing yards and yards per carry.

If anything, Wallace’s 6 yards per carry, which ranks No. 3 in the Big Ten, could have produced a much larger output this season if he had received his featured role earlier.

Jamie Lynch: Whoa, let’s get crazy here.

In the past three weeks, Hansen has put up 341 rushing yards on 43 carries, which is about as good a three-game span as one could ask for. Right now, in Big Ten play, Hansen stands alone with those stats over that stretch.

The conference is nowhere near as top-heavy as it was last year, with Nebraska running back Emmett Johnson and Kaytron Allen leading the charge. I don’t think it’s crazy to say Hansen would’ve been competing among the Big Ten’s best if the pieces around him had clicked early on.

Funny enough, one of Campbell’s recruits who’s currently playing at Iowa State, Aiden Flora, is having one of the best seasons in college football. If you factor in Breece Hall from many years ago, it’s clear the head coach has an eye for elite rushing talent.

Oscar Orellana: Hansen is No. 11 in Big Ten rushing yards despite only eclipsing 50 yards on the ground twice before Penn State’s bye week, and while he was splitting (and sometimes getting fewer) carries than Wallace, Peoples, and Quinton Martin Jr.

Hansen has especially looked like an all-conference back in the past two weeks. His patience and brute style of running set him apart from the quick dashers of the Big Ten, and he’s made the Penn State offense a completely different unit.

It’s hard to talk about what could have been, but Hansen, Campbell, and Mouser have continuously pointed to the offensive line’s improvement as what’s made the run game so much better in recent weeks.

If that level of protection were present from the very beginning, I think we would be having very, very different conversations about Hansen heading into the postseason on a national level.

Top running back in the Big Ten, though? Maybe still a bit of a stretch. But shoutout to Hansen nonetheless.

Your ad blocker is on.

Please choose an option below.

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter:
OR
Support quality journalism:
Purchase a Subscription!

About the Author

Staff

Posts from the all-student staff of Onward State.

Penn State Submits Proposal To Host New United States Space Academy

Penn State would lead the curriculum USSA students would learn under.

Penn State Football Long Snapper Blaise Sokach-Minnick Named Patrick Mannelly Award Semifinalist

The honor is handed out annually to the nation’s top long snapper. 

Penn State Women’s Soccer To Open NCAA Tournament Against Villanova

Make that 32 consecutive NCAA Tournament berths for the Nittany Lions!

113kFollowers
72.5kFollowers
16.8kFollowers
TrendingPast 48 hours