Fourth-Down Struggles Prove Costly In Penn State Football’s Loss To Rutgers

Football is a game of downs. For Penn State football, it was fourth down that cost it in the team’s 25-24 loss to Rutgers on Saturday night.
Despite jumping out to a 16-0 lead in the first half, the Nittany Lions felt as if they should have walked away with more, if not for two turnovers on downs deep in Scarlet Knight territory.
“We’ve been really good at it. I think we’ve been as good as anybody, all season, to be quite honest, with the short-yardage situations,” Matt Campbell said postgame. “I think the thing that’s really frustrating is, at this point of the season, to regress and not be as good at it tonight. And I don’t know exactly what that [reason why] is. We’ll evaluate it. But obviously, we didn’t have a good enough plan to be able to execute.”
In the first quarter, Penn State strung together a 14-play drive, its longest of the game, but wasn’t able to convert after a series with three rushes and a sack resulted in Rutgers stuffing Rocco Becht on fourth down at the goal line.
The Nittany Lion defense partially made up for it with a safety on the next play from scrimmage, but it was a clear example of a time when Penn State should have walked away with six points, not two.
In a game that came down to one point, that four-point swing was unfortunately the difference.
“Coming up short at the goal line and short yardage hurt us big time,” offensive lineman Anthony Donkoh said. “On offense, we got to do a better job in those situations because we left points on the board doing that.”
On the Nittany Lions’ subsequent offensive possession, three Cam Wallace rushes up the middle, with a short Andrew Rappleyea completion mixed in, yielded a similar result.
Becht completed a deep ball to wideout Chase Sowell in the series prior, but Penn State offense completely stalled and gave Rutgers the football back at its own 29-yard line after another failed fourth-and-1 conversion.
“I think just being aggressive, and I love the way that we did that,” Becht said about the team’s late-down struggles. “Obviously, we didn’t get it on the goal line, but just continuing to stay aggressive, I think, is the biggest thing, and we’ve got to be able to continue to do that.”
As much as fourth down was a problem for the offense, the defense also had trouble getting off the field in such situations.
While Penn State went 0-2 in that category, Rutgers converted three out of four times.
In the fourth quarter, Scarlet Knight wide receiver Dyzier Carter went up to make a catch on fourth-and-6, allowing Rutgers to extend its drive. Quarterback AJ Surace found Carter again four plays later, this time on fourth-and-10, which the wideout turned into a first down.
Rutgers scored a touchdown to cap off its 19-play drive, the longest of the game for either team.
“I think we were in a great position a lot of those plays. It was just, man, [Rutgers] made the play in the moment. I think that’s what college football is all about, winning your moment,” linebacker Kooper Ebel said. “Whether it’s a pass interference, or if it’s they go up and high point a ball and make a play on fourth down, whatever it is, we got to win the moment. We can’t leave it to chance.”
Campbell believes the issue lies in a weak mentality more than anything.
Eleven games into the season, he still feels as if his team lacks the killer instinct it needs to find success in the face of adversity.
“Our ability to do hard things is still escaping this team from becoming its best, and you know, hard is playing great defense in the third and fourth quarter. Hard’s playing great offense down from the 1-yard line, down on a fourth-and-1 situation,” Campbell said.
Penn State suffered another tally in the loss column because it couldn’t take advantage in critical moments yet again, failing to close out the game with the upper hand.
It’s been a problem since Week 4, and it was obvious even during a string of Big Ten wins that another team would expose the Nittany Lions’ shortcomings down the road.
Tonight, those shortcomings came on fourth down, in what really was a game of inches.
“You felt like you were in control of the game, and then after that, you could never play complementary football,” Campbell said. “The offense goes down, scores in the third quarter, you feel like you’re in a great spot. And then, you give up two long drives. You just felt like you never had the ability to put the final blow in. I think that’s continued to be a challenge for this team.”
Your ad blocker is on.
Please choose an option below.
Purchase a Subscription!



