Four golds and one bronze were secured among the six wrestlers with Penn State ties.
A late rally from High Point forced set five, which Penn State captured despite another Wildcat comeback.
The Nittany Lions' next game is now scheduled for September 4.
The Penn State freshmen made their mark on the Nittany Lions' first win of the season.
Head coach Rob Dow was suspended for the game.
Penn State scored three unanswered goals in the fourth quarter to send the game into overtime.