Jack Iannantuono took home Big Ten Freshman of the Year.
The Nittany Lions will hope for an at-large bid to compete in the NCAA Tournament.
McFadden ended 2025-26 with back-to-back double-digit scoring efforts.
Sean Harvey was also named EIVA Player of the Year.
Pavlik and Penn State aim to finish strong in the coach's final EIVA Tournament.
Michael Anderson launched his 17th and 18th home runs in Tuesday evening's game.