Penn State news by
Penn State's student blog



HUB Titles: Dinner for Schmucks

Once again, I find myself watching a movie starring Steve Carell. However, this time he is not a cartoon character. Not that he’s any less animated. Horrible puns aside, Steve Carell has livened up every show he’s done, from “The Daily Show,” to “Saturday Night Live,” to “The Office.” But what if he had to try to make a movie good on his talent alone? “Dinner for Schmucks” answers that question.

The Premise: The business world has not been kind to Tim Conrad (Paul Rudd). He’s stuck in “Office Space” but dreams of moving up on the corporate ladder. In order to be a big shot, he agrees to attend his jerk boss Lance Fender’s (Bruce Greenwood) “dinner for idiots.” The idea is to bring “special” people to a dinner and mock them. Being far from New Jersey, Tim’s search for an idiot seems hopeless until he runs into Barry Speck (Steve Carell). Barry and Tim engage in wacky hijinks for a while, but Barry’s antics cause trouble between Tim and his girlfriend Julie (Stephanie Szostak). Tim has to balance his life, his job, his girlfriend… and Barry.

The Performance: The story focuses around Paul Rudd’s character, but he is merely the straight man to Steve Carell’s nuttiness. Carell brings the energy only he can to this role. Unfortunately, the role is unworthy of him. He and Rudd are basically a comedy team, but Rudd can’t hold up his end of the comedy deal. The only laughs from this movie will be caused by scenes including Carell. He manages to beef up what would otherwise be average writing. All of the other actors besides Carell are there to fill the usual rundown of comedy roles: the plain dude, the girlfriend, the boss, the rival, etc. The one exception is Barry’s boss Therman Murch, played by Zach Galifianakis. Carell and Galifianakis work great together, and their exchanges are the most memorable parts of the movie. All two of them. A shame.

Other Thoughts: I wonder what would have happened if Paul Rudd and Zach Galifianakis mixed up scripts. Carell and Galifianakis would make one hell of a comedy duo, I’m sure. It says something when they can pull some laughs out of a rather uninteresting premise. They are funny in spite of this movie and not because of it. The script under-utilizes both of them, and I’m thinking their best jokes were likely ad libbed. Take them out of the cast and this movie is very forgettable. As it is, they take a bland film and bump it up to an average one. The fact that almost every sentence of this review contains or alludes to them merely proves my point.

Final Verdict: The Clown in the Library. It isn’t completely devoid of laughs, but each one takes a lot of effort. It’s basically a one man show that’s steeped in mediocrity. You’ll enjoy yourself in intervals. Expect long stretches in between chuckle worthy occurrences. Essentially, it’s just a distraction and you probably could have spent your time better somewhere else.  

Your ad blocker is on.

Please choose an option below.

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter:
Support quality journalism:
Purchase a Subscription!

About the Author

John Dempsey

John is a Junior majoring in Journalism from Hazleton, PA. He is so awesome that sharks dedicate a week to him.
Likes: Video games, vigilante justice, irony, talking bears, Burt Reynolds, El Chupacabra, coloring books, chainsaws, and Australians.
Dislikes: Zombies, clowns, zombie clowns, turtleneck sweaters, Apple, poor mustache grooming, nuclear winter, Roman architecture, guacamole, robots, LCD TVs, the color yellow, Velcro, ceiling fans, sprinklers, tornadoes, Belgians, squat thrusts, and romantic comedies.

‘One Possession At A Time’: Lady Lions’ Carolyn Kieger Promises Rebound Through Six-Game Skid

“I believe we can do it. I believe we have the depth. Thirteen women in there got to believe it.”

Four For Four: Justin Stempowski Rounds Out Family Of Dancers At THON 2024

“I’m really glad I did it, and I’m really glad I listened to my sister for once.”

Zach Hicks’ Recent Efficiency Leading To Penn State Hoops Success

Hicks has scored double-digit points in the past seven games.

Follow on Another Platform
Other posts by John

The 3 Keys to Never Graduating

It is that time of year again. The weather is getting warmer when it feels like it and we switch to shorter pants just as the insects begin to multiply. It is a magical time of year that some of us will see for the last time in State College. For those lucky few, not going to class this week is a sign of maturity. With a college degree ensured, the world awaits you. Unless you’re in the Liberal Arts, of course. Then, your mother’s couch awaits you. However, there exist among us the ones that dare to take it to the next level. The ones that can’t get enough binge drinking, construction, and parking citations. The ones that will never graduate. How do they do it? Very, very smugly. These are the keys to never leaving Penn State.

Playboy Says PSU is 2nd Best at Partying

PSU Presses Start on Video Game Class