Skeller Saved? Herlocher Family Says New Operators Plan To Keep Bar ‘The Way You’ve Always Known It’

Penn Staters came out in droves Monday night against the impending closure of The All-American Rathskeller, a prohibition-era bar that’s become legendary in downtown State College since its opening in 1933.

More than 6,500 individuals signed a petition to save the Skeller and adjoining Spats Café, and #SaveTheSkeller was used more than 1,500 times in less than 24 hours. Penn Staters near and far pledged to boycott the Herlocher family’s mustard empire, leaving more than 850 one-star reviews on the Herlocher’s Dipping Mustard Facebook page before the reviews section was ultimately disabled. Even mayor-elect Don Hahn weighed in, saying, “…if there is a way to persuade the Herlochers to change their plans, perhaps a public appeal to their sense of community, I would be very interested.”

Now it seems The Skeller won’t face the guillotine after all.

The Herlocher family released an open letter Tuesday afternoon addressed to the Penn State and State College communities, insisting on their shared value of tradition in this town we all know and love. Though the family still hasn’t identified the new tenants of the location, the letter says they plan to “continue operating the Skeller the way you’ve always known it.”

The Herlochers said they’ll announce the new operators before the end of the year. They said in a statement Monday night the new operators are interested in retaining staff.

“Rest assured, these Penn Staters share your passion and have great familiarity with the Skeller and its rich history,” the Herlochers said in the letter. “From the start, we understood the responsibility to honor the tradition. We believe together, we will create a future that reflects the goal of all who want to #SaveTheSkellar.”

Though the Herlochers’ open letter addressed The Rathskeller, it did not mention the fate of the adjoining Spats Café. Owners Duke and Monica Gastinger told the Centre Daily Times Monday they would consider re-opening Spats at another location, but that the Skeller wouldn’t be the same anywhere else.

Your ad blocker is on.

Please choose an option below.

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter:
Support quality journalism:
Purchase a Subscription!

About the Author

Elissa Hill

Elissa was the managing editor of Onward State from 2017-2019. She is from Punxsutawney, PA [insert corny Bill Murray joke here] and considers herself an expert on all things ice cream. Follow her on Twitter (@ElissaKHill) for more corny jokes.

Penn State Football Preparing For Defensive Adjustments As New Big Ten Dawns

“Bottom line is, the game has changed. And we got to be able to adapt to it, and we will.”

All 2024 Arts Fest Performances Free

No events from Wednesday, July 10, through Sunday, July 14, will require buttons nor wristbands to enter.

Penn State Women’s Volleyball Picks Up Two Commitments

Danielle Whitmire and Finley Krystkowiak committed to the Nittany Lions in quick succession.

Other posts by Elissa

2020 Blue-White Game To Kick Off April 18

More details will be announced following the 2019 season, but the game is usually scheduled for a mid-afternoon kickoff and aired live on BTN.

Penn State Football Announces First Five Kickoff Times For 2019 Season

Behring, Barlow, Engeman, & Marshall Secure Democratic Nominations For State College Borough Council