PSU news by
Penn State's student blog

Topics

More

Poor Officiating Nearly Overshadows Penn State-Iowa Game

Penn State football’s 17-12 victory over Iowa was almost ruined by an absolutely brutal display of officiating.

John O’Neill — who’s had his fair share of poor performances when officiating Penn State football games — was the lead referee on Saturday night. He and his crew definitely weren’t on point during the game, including one particular sequence in the third quarter.

Pat Freiermuth, Journey Brown, and Sean Clifford all scored touchdowns on the drive, but all three scores were called back due to penalties and, in Freiermuth’s case, a botched review. The referees determined that Freiermuth’s knee touched the turf before he broke the plane on this play:

Journey Brown then punched in a one-yard touchdown, but holding was called on the play to wipe the score off the board. Sean Clifford ran the ball into the end zone from 10 yards out on the first play after the hold, but Steven Gonzalez took a borderline-at-best holding penalty to negate that score. Penn State eventually settled for a Jake Pinegar field goal to extend its lead to 10-6.

That’s not to mention Nate Stanley’s incompletion that was initially called a fumble returned for a touchdown on the field in the fourth quarter. Stanley was hit as he threw while passing out of his own end zone, and the hit caused him to spike the ball into the turf.

Ellis Brooks scooped up the ball and dove into the end zone, and one of the officials instantly signaled “touchdown.” However, O’Neill instantly stepped in and said the ruling on the field was an incomplete pass. That call was objectively correct, but the fact that O’Neill was completely out of sync with his colleagues was another black eye on Saturday night’s officiating performance.

The Nittany Lions took just 4.2 penalties per game through their first five games in 2019. Tonight, the officials threw eight flags on Penn State that cost the team 80 yards. Something’s obviously not right here, and James Franklin knows it.

“The thing that was really interesting is that we’re one of the least penalized teams in the country,” head coach James Franklin said postgame. “We come in here tonight, and it didn’t play out that way. I’ll just leave it at that.”

When asked if he got an explanation for why Freiermuth’s would-be touchdown was wiped off the board, Franklin’s response was simple: “No.” According to the Harrisburg-Patriot News’ David Jones, Big Ten officials said that the decision to overturn Freiermuth’s touchdown was a “judgment call” without providing any further explanation.

Although the head coach admitted he’d love to have a long-winded discussion about the officials’ struggles on Saturday night, Franklin held his tongue during his postgame press conference.

“I’d love to have a lengthy conversation about this,” Franklin said. “I know our fans want me to have a lengthy conversation about this. It’s not going to do anything. We’re going to enjoy the win and focus on the things we can control. I get it, but I’m in a no-win situation.”

John O’Neill definitely has a history of poorly officiating Penn State football games. He was the lead official for the 2014 White Out game against Ohio State, and he and replay official Tom Fiedler called a pass that clearly touched the ground an interception for Ohio State’s Vonn Bell. Additionally, the Buckeyes snapped the ball and converted a 49-yard field goal a full three seconds after the play clock expired. A delay of game penalty wasn’t called on Ohio State, and the three-pointer stood. Penn State lost that game 31-24 in double-overtime.

At the end of the day, O’Neill’s incompetence doesn’t matter all that much. Penn State went 1-0 this week and beat a ranked opponent on the road for the first time in the James Franklin era.

Your ad blocker is on.

Please choose an option below.

Sign up for our e-mail newsletter:
OR
Support quality journalism:
Purchase a Subscription!

About the Author

Mikey Mandarino

Mikey is a senior majoring in journalism and Onward State's Sports Editor. He grew up in Bedminster, NJ and is way too obnoxious about all the best things his home state has to offer. Mikey loves to play golf, but he sucks at it because golf is hard. If you're dying to see more hockey/golf content on your timeline, you can follow Mikey on Twitter @mikey_mandarino. Send all hate mail, death threats, and your vote for the best chicken parm in State College to [email protected]

Comments

Other posts by Mikey

Ohio State Star Chase Young Suspended For Two Games, Will Play Against Penn State

Young was initially suspended indefinitely on November 8, and he’s now been officially ruled out of the Buckeyes’ game of the year against Penn State.

James Franklin Responds To Media Criticism Of Decisions Made In Minnesota Game

James Franklin: Noah Cain Was ‘90%’ Healthy Against Minnesota

Staff Picks: The Best Flow In Penn State Athletics

With so many amazing flows across Penn State sports, our staff decided to make its case for which Nittany Lion has the best hair.

Get To Know Penn State’s Winter Sports Student Sections

From the Roar Zone to Legion of Blue, get to know the student sections that root on Penn State’s winter sports teams.

Send this to a friend