Penn State will face Harvard -- the Ivy League champions -- at 2:30 p.m. on Friday. The winner takes on either Princeton or Virginia on Sunday.
Myles Dread, Lamar Stevens, and Josh Reaves played well against the Mountaineers, but the Nittany Lions need Mike Watkins to earn an NCAA tournament bid.
Zain Retherford, Nico Megaludis, Dan Vallimont, and Frank Molinaro will all compete in the American Wrestle League.
Penn State men's soccer failed to capitalize on Ryan Gallagher's first half goal and dropped its final match of the season to the Wolverines.
The Golden Gophers prevailed 5-4 in penalty kicks following a scoreless 110 minutes of play Sunday afternoon.
Barratt scooped the puck up on the blade of his stick and shoveled it past Arizona State's goalie in the Nittany Lions' 4-3 overtime loss on Saturday.